
Are we unknowingly killing our children’s
creativity – and more importantly, how can we stop?
Psychologist Teresa Amabile, a Harvard Business
School professor and noted creativity researcher,
has identified six main creativity killers:
1. Surveillance
Constant hovering over children, making them feel
watched, can cause imagination stage fright. The
creator needs personal space to explore, take risks,
make mistakes and change direction. Every superhero
battle shouldn’t be a Kodak moment. There is a
reason kids lose interest once the video is rolling.
If they want you at the tea party, they will ask –
but understand why they may not.
2. Valuation
In business, an idea is only valuable if it
works. In childhood, there are no creative misfires,
for it’s the process not the product that matters.
What valuation really means is to bite your tongue.
Let a Valentine be orange with dinosaurs, a too-tall
block tower fall (again), and a pine derby car have
lopsided wheels. Be your child’s cheerleader always,
but his coach only when asked. A child who worries
how others judge what he is doing won’t push open
the box. Self-satisfaction, however, drives more
creation.
“One of the most common mistakes I see parents make
is correcting them for answers that are really just
different ways of viewing something or saying
something,” Morton says. “Parents need to understand
that the way their child views things is a unique
personality trait that sets their child apart from
the rest. In fact, listening to their make-believe
and joining in will further spark their creativity
and create great memories between parent and child.”
3. Rewards & Competition
Recognize but do not specifically reward creative
thinking. Research shows rewards actually interfere
with the creative process. Incentives motivate
ideas, but not as many original ones. Authentic
exploration stops after all possibilities have been
tried. When the goal becomes the good grade, there
is less motivation to explore beyond the first right
answer.
Win/lose situations also defeat creativity. Creative
spirit is about playing vs. final score. Children
need permission to progress at their own rate,
taking pride in their own ideas. Parents need to
muzzle their own competitive spirit. For example, I
was quite proud of my son’s Western-themed bedroom,
with it’s stylish comforter, matching lamp and
wrought-iron mirror. “But I don’t like cowboys,
Mommy,” he said. And I hadn’t bothered asking him
for fear he might pick an ugly licensed character.
His room is now “sports” themed – a hodge-podge of
trophies, sports banners and a not-so-sophisticated
comforter, all picked and enjoyed by him.
4. Over-control
Telling children exactly how to do something of a
creative nature also tells them exploration is a
waste of time and originality is wrong. Perhaps you
are familiar with Henry Chapin’s classic, “Flowers
are Red,” which tells the demise of a child’s
imagination at the hands of a teacher who insists,
“Flowers are red, green leaves are green…There’s no
need to see flowers any other way…than the way they
always have been seen.”
According to Kent, “the coloring example” is a
classic case of a well-intending adult ignoring a
child’s creativity. A child has a coloring sheet
featuring a tree outline, and thus grabs purples, pinks, blues and begins
to color all over the page. The adult tries to
“teach” the child that coloring is done inside the
lines and with correct tree colors. The adult never
considers that the child might be using colors that
she wanted trees to be, or maybe she was actually
using colors and lines that reflected the tree’s
movement or mood.
Despite good intentions, the adult “taught” that
being original is not acceptable.
This stifling of spontaneous creativity happens
in more mundane ways as well: insisting that blue
socks don’t match yellow dresses, that the holiday
star must be displayed atop the tree, or that peanut
butter can’t go on a turkey sandwich. “Actively look
for opportunities for your child to fill in the
blanks,” Kent says.
5. Pressure
The performance of 73 percent of all Major League
Baseball rookies of the year declines during their
second season. We make trivia games of one-hit
wonders, but their quick burnout speaks to a highly
destructive creativity killer – grand expectations.
Type A parents anticipate Type A accomplishment from
a child who shows creative “promise.” Amabile warns
that too-intensive training can result in a total
distaste for the talent being cultivated.
6. Time
The deadliest of all creativity killers is
something so obvious, it’s not. Time. Children need
blocks of uninterrupted, open-ended time. Time for
what psychologists call “flow” – the ultimate state
of creativity, in which a person becomes so
completely absorbed in an activity that he or she
loses all sense of time.
As a parent you know how easily children flow
into flow. Yet we typically interrupt them to move
on to the next activity. Many parents have an
irrational fear of allowing a child to become bored.
In reality, boredom drives fantasy and imagination.
Says Morton, “I see children going from piano to
gymnastics to soccer on a daily basis. These
children don’t have any free playtime. They don’t
have enough time to daydream or create.”
Over-scheduling is a tired topic – but I’ll still
refer to our multi-task culture that devalues
under-scheduled time. Not just for our children, but
for ourselves.
And that’s where the real truth lies. The No. 1
creativity killer for children is parents’ lack of
undivided attention to really listen: to pick up on
and run with kids’ creative cues. Kids constantly
invite brainstorming, but adults are often too
preoccupied with their own ideas to hear.
Most parents don’t always have or take the time
to treat children’s unusual questions with proper
respect. It’s quicker and easier to provide an
answer than to answer with a question that
encourages further thinking. We all dismiss ready
opportunities to brainstorm with children. Typical
example: “I wish we could fly over this traffic,” my
daughter reports. “We’ll be there soon; would you
like to hear Kids Bop?” I respond. Another Big Idea
lost somewhere on Ga. 400.